Your Website & Content Need to Have These Essential Things

Thanks for reading. Feedback?
Reply to this email or message [email protected]

Let’s get into it

Your Website & Content Need to Have These Essential Things

Evaluation criteria will help AI-proof your content. Let me explain.

AI agents don’t wait for instructions.

When someone types “best CRM for small businesses” or “top HVAC company near me,” ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini don’t just list random options.

They evaluate every brand they know.

And if your site doesn’t clearly show the facts that help them make that decision, you’ll be invisible.

Let’s unpack what that means, why it matters, and how to fix it.

The Hidden Evaluation System Behind Every AI Answer

AI agents are trained to think like decision-makers.

They look for structure, clarity, and confidence before recommending anything.

When a user says “best,” “top,” or “most affordable,” the AI automatically runs a checklist in the background.

It looks for:

• Pricing

• Features

• Audience fit

• Reviews and trust signals

• Popularity and authority

• Specific use cases or contexts

Even if the user doesn’t mention those things, the AI infers them.

That’s how it builds confidence in its answer.

So if your brand doesn’t display this information clearly, the AI will fill in the blanks…usually with data from your competitors. Yuck.

Why “Evaluation Criteria” Are the New Ranking Factors

In traditional SEO, you optimized for keywords and backlinks.

In AI search, you’re optimizing for evaluation signals aka the factual and qualitative markers that help the model justify why you deserve to be cited.

Think of them as your decision metadata aka the structured details that let an AI answer with authority.

There are three main types:

1. Quantitative criteria:

Facts and measurements that are easy to verify.

• Pricing

• Product specs

• Delivery times

• Feature counts

• Warranty lengths

2. Qualitative criteria:

Signals that show trust and satisfaction.

• Reviews and testimonials

• Case studies

• Brand authority content

• Certifications and awards

3. Comparative criteria:

How you stand apart.

• “More affordable than X”

• “Built for small teams”

• “Fastest turnaround in the industry”

AI agents connect these dots automatically.

Your job is to make them obvious, structured, and up to date.

What Every Business Type Should Include

Different industries need different evaluation signals.

Here’s what matters most depending on your business type.

For E-Commerce and Product Brands

Your product pages should include:

• Clear pricing or price ranges

• Material, size, and weight specs

• Delivery times and return policies

• Verified reviews and average star ratings

• Photos and videos of the product

• Category fit or use case (“Best for apartment kitchens”)

Don’t just make it look good visually —> structure it.

Add schema markup for products, reviews, and FAQs so agents can parse it instantly.

If two brands sell similar blenders but only one includes detailed specs and verified reviews, guess which one the AI recommends?

For B2B SaaS Companies

SaaS is where clarity and trust win.

Your site should show:

• Transparent pricing or ranges

• Feature breakdowns and comparison tables

• Integrations (“Works with HubSpot, Slack, Salesforce”)

• Industry fit (“Built for fintech compliance teams”)

• Case studies with ROI metrics

• Security and compliance credentials (SOC 2, ISO 27001, GDPR-ready)

The biggest mistake SaaS companies make is hiding pricing behind a “Contact Sales” button.

That ambiguity makes it harder for AI agents to evaluate you, so they promote someone else.

For Service Businesses (Agencies, Law Firms, Consultants)

Agents care about transparency and proof of outcomes.

Show:

• Pricing models (“Flat fee”, “Hourly”, “Performance-based”)

• Service tiers (“Starter”, “Growth”, “Enterprise”)

• Industries you specialize in

• Team credentials and certifications

• Testimonials with measurable results (“Cut lead cost by 40%”)

• Estimated turnaround times

If a user asks ChatGPT “best law firm for startups,” the model pulls data on rates, client reviews, and industries served.

If your site doesn’t include that, it can’t justify picking you.

For Local Businesses

Local AI search runs on trust and proximity.

List:

• Your service area

• Operating hours

• Pricing transparency (“$79 tune-up special”)

• Reviews with context

• Photos of your team or location

• Local authority signals (Chamber of Commerce, BBB badges, Google Business Profile links)

Local schema and consistent contact info are critical.

If that data isn’t visible or structured, the AI can’t match you to “near me” or city-based queries.

How to Make It AI-Readable

You don’t need a developer army to make this work…just consistency.

Here’s how to embed your evaluation criteria into your content and product pages:

Use structured data (schema).

Add schema for pricing, reviews, FAQs, and product info.

• That’s the language AI agents natively understand.

Use comparison tables.

• Don’t just say you’re better. Show the differences in plain text.

Keep your information current.

• Outdated pricing, broken links, or inconsistent copy destroy trust.

Make it visible in text.

• AI models read HTML, not design. Don’t hide details in graphics or PDFs.

Every time you update your website, think about whether an AI could easily summarize what you sell, who it’s for, and why it’s credible.

If not, you’ve got work to do.

Make It Part of Your Brand Guidelines

This isn’t a one-time SEO tweak.

It’s a brand habit.

Add a “Decision Criteria” checklist to your content and marketing operations.

Before you publish anything, ask:

• Does this page show pricing or value?

• Does it show proof and trust?

• Does it specify who it’s for?

• Does it include factual, structured data?

You can even create an internal style guide section called “AI Visibility Signals.”

That keeps your team aligned on how to make your brand agent-readable.

Prioritize Signal Hierarchy

Not all criteria carry the same weight.

Here’s how AI agents typically prioritize:

Primary signals:

• Price, reviews, features, specs.

Secondary signals:

• Support quality, delivery times, return policies.

Contextual signals:

• Audience fit, industry relevance, credibility.

The more intent-driven the query, the more those top-level signals matter.

“Best budget software” leans on price and reviews.

“Enterprise payroll system” leans on trust and compliance.

Match your signals to your buyer intent.

The Outcome: Trusted, Cited, Chosen

When your brand communicates its evaluation criteria clearly, three things happen:

1. You get cited more often in AI-generated answers.

2. You get recommended for “best” and “top” category queries.

3. You future-proof your visibility for the agent-powered internet.

You’re not just optimizing for keywords anymore. You’re also optimizing for confidence.

Confidence that the AI can justify your inclusion.

Confidence that the user will trust the recommendation.

That’s how you win in AI search.

Final Thought

AI agents don’t guess.

They evaluate.

If you want to show up, make it easy for them to choose you.

Make your pricing, features, audience, and proof unmistakably clear…in both human-readable and AI-readable formats.

The businesses that do this now will own the next decade of visibility.

Jason Patel
Co-founder & CEO, Open Forge AI
We help your business get seen, cited, and selected by AI search engines.

Answer Engine Optimization Strategies

If you liked this newsletter, feel free to forward to your friends in marketing and AI.

If you got this from a friend, you can sign up to get the newsletter: https://aen.beehiiv.com/subscribe