Thanks for reading. Feedback?
Reply to this email or message [email protected]

Subscribe to My YouTube Channel
 

Let’s get into it

Why Keyword Rankings Don't Matter In AI Search (And What Actually Does)

The $90 billion SEO industry is built on an outdated principle that's about to collapse.

While outdated agencies are still selling you keyword rankings and position tracking, AI search engines are completely ignoring your #1 Google rankings and pulling answers from Reddit threads, Quora posts, and obscure blog comments instead.

Here's what's really happening.

The Death of Traditional Keyword Rankings

The reality check that SEO agencies don't want you to know:

• Google's AI Overviews rarely pull from top 3 organic results

• Analysis of 10,000 AI Overview responses shows 60% of citations come from positions 4-20

• ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity don't even look at Google rankings when sourcing information

• The "10 blue links" model is dying as users get direct answers

Why position #1 doesn't equal AI visibility:

A client spent $15,000 per month for eight months to achieve #1 rankings for "project management software."

They were thrilled with their SEO success.

Until they realized they were getting zero mentions in AI search responses. Zero.

Meanwhile, a competitor with much lower Google rankings was being recommended by ChatGPT consistently because they had better distributed authority signals.

The economics of wasted SEO spend:

• Companies spending $10K+ monthly on keyword ranking improvements

• Zero correlation between ranking improvements and AI search visibility

• Traditional SEO metrics (domain authority, backlinks, keyword density) mean nothing to AI models

• The disconnect between what ranks and what gets cited is growing daily

User behavior is shifting fast:

People are asking AI assistants for recommendations instead of clicking through multiple search results.

They want direct answers, not lists of links to evaluate.

When AI provides those answers, it's pulling from sources that demonstrate expertise and provide value, not sources that happen to rank well for specific keywords.

What AI Search Engines Actually Care About

If AI search engines don't care about keyword rankings, what do they care about?

Authority and expertise signals:

• AI models identify subject matter experts through content depth, not keyword optimization

• How AI evaluates credibility: citations, cross-references, technical accuracy

• Why a detailed Reddit comment can outrank a perfectly optimized landing page

• The importance of demonstrating genuine expertise vs gaming algorithms

Content context and user intent matching:

AI understands user intent at a granular level that keywords can't capture.

Example: "best CRM" vs "CRM for real estate teams with mobile agents"

• AI matches specific use cases to relevant solutions

• The shift from keyword targeting to intent serving

• Nuanced requirements matter more than broad keyword targets

Cross-platform mention frequency:

• AI aggregates information from multiple sources before making recommendations

• Brands mentioned across Reddit, Quora, YouTube, and industry forums win

• The "mention velocity" factor that traditional SEO ignores

• Consistent messaging across platforms builds AI credibility

Real-time relevance and freshness:

• AI prioritizes current, up-to-date information over historical rankings

• Recent mentions and discussions influence AI recommendations

• Declining value of aged, highly-ranked content

• News mentions and recent reviews matter more than backlinks

The New Rules of AI Search Optimization

Strategy 1: Distributed authority building

Your company blog is just one piece of a larger puzzle.

• Create expertise signals across multiple platforms simultaneously

• Establish thought leadership on Reddit, Quora, and industry forums

• The compound effect of multi-platform expertise demonstration

• Each platform where you establish credibility reinforces your authority on other platforms

Strategy 2: Conversation-driven content creation

Stop targeting search terms. Start participating in ongoing conversations.

• Write content that answers specific questions, not targets keywords

• Identify the questions your AI audience is actually asking

• Create "quotable" content that AI models can easily extract and cite

• Master writing for AI synthesis rather than human browsing

Strategy 3: Third-party validation systems

Customer reviews and user-generated content carry more weight with AI.

• Build systems to encourage authentic mentions across platforms

• Amplify positive customer experiences beyond your own website

• The strategic value of being discussed rather than self-promoting

• Platforms like G2, Capterra, and Trustpilot become crucial for AI visibility

Strategy 4: Contextual relevance optimization

• Understand how AI models categorize and relate different topics

• Create content clusters that establish comprehensive expertise

• Position your brand for relevant adjacent topics and use cases

• The importance of semantic relationships over keyword relationships

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

The keyword addiction problem:

Marketers who've spent years thinking in terms of search volume and keyword difficulty struggle to abandon this framework.

• Why marketers struggle to abandon keyword-focused thinking

• How to retrain your team for relevance-based optimization

• Common transition mistakes that waste time and resources

Platform diversification errors:

• Focusing too heavily on owned media vs earned media

• Neglecting platforms where your audience actually discusses your industry

• The balance between brand control and authentic engagement

Timeline and expectation management:

• AI optimization takes longer to show results than traditional SEO

• Building distributed authority and earning organic mentions takes months, not weeks

• The results tend to be more sustainable than traditional SEO gains

Don't abandon traditional SEO overnight:

While AI search is growing rapidly, traditional search engines still drive significant traffic for most businesses.

The smart approach is gradually shifting budget allocation while maintaining some traditional SEO efforts.

Avoid trying to manipulate AI systems:

AI models are sophisticated at detecting and deprioritizing content that feels like marketing rather than genuine expertise sharing.

Focus on providing real value in every interaction rather than trying to promote your products directly.

What This Means for Your Business

Immediate action items:

• Search for your industry topics using ChatGPT and Claude right now

• Notice which sources they cite (they're not necessarily the #1 ranking pages)

• Study why AI trusts those sources

• Build similar distributed expertise

Budget reallocation strategy:

• Start shifting from traditional SEO to AI optimization

• Aim for 70/30 split favoring AI optimization within 12 months

• Adjust based on your industry and audience behavior

Success metrics that actually matter:

• Track brand mentions in AI-generated responses

• Monitor share of voice in AI recommendations vs competitors

• Measure increases in direct traffic that can't be attributed to traditional sources

• Survey customers about how they discovered your brand

The Bottom Line

While your competitors waste budget chasing rankings that AI ignores, you can dominate AI search by becoming the expert worth quoting.

Key principles:

• Relevance beats rankings

• Authority beats optimization

• Conversations beat keywords

• Expertise beats manipulation

The future belongs to brands that participate in discussions, not manipulate algorithms.

The mindset shift:

Keywords target search behavior. AI optimization targets conversation participation.

Instead of asking "what keywords do people search?" ask "what questions do people discuss?"

Then become the expert those discussions naturally reference.

Companies spend hundreds of thousands annually chasing rankings that have zero correlation with AI search visibility.

Meanwhile, competitors with lower Google rankings dominate AI recommendations because they built authentic authority across platforms.

The choice is yours: keep fighting yesterday's war or start winning tomorrow's.

Jason Patel
Co-founder & CEO, Open Forge AI
We help your business get seen, cited, and selected by AI search engines.

Answer Engine Optimization Strategies and Tips

If you liked this newsletter, feel free to forward to your friends in marketing and AI.

If you got this from a friend, you can sign up to get the newsletter: https://aen.beehiiv.com/subscribe