These Websites are the Backbone of the AI Search Economy

Thanks for reading. Feedback?
Reply to this email or message [email protected]

Let’s get into it

These Websites are the Backbone of the
AI Search Economy

With AI search, they're twice as important as before.

We live in a world where there’s simply too much information.

Every company claims to be the best. Every website promises the same results. Every ad feels slightly exaggerated.

And when everything starts to sound the same, people stop believing what brands say about themselves.

That’s why review sites have become so powerful. They cut through the noise.

They give people something they can actually trust aka the words of other customers.

And here’s the part that most businesses still don’t realize.

It’s not just humans who trust review sites anymore. ChatGPT does too.

The Human Side: Trust Has Moved Off Your Website

Ten years ago, a buyer might visit your homepage, read a few blog posts, and decide if they liked your company. That’s not how it works anymore.

Today, people skip the homepage. They go straight to your reviews.

If you sell software or services, your buyers are probably checking:

• G2

• Capterra

• TrustRadius

• Gartner Peer Insights

• Clutch

• UpCity

If you sell to consumers, they’re going to:

• Google Reviews

• Yelp

• Trustpilot

• TripAdvisor

• Amazon Reviews

• Angi (formerly Angie’s List)

They read what others say about your product, how fast your team responds, and how you handle mistakes.

In many cases, that single experience - reading a handful of authentic reviews - shapes their entire perception of your brand.

It doesn’t matter how clean your website is or how polished your case studies are. If your reviews look outdated, sparse, or overly curated, you’ve already lost credibility.

The AI Side: ChatGPT Crawls Review Sites Too

Now here’s where things get interesting.

AI search engines like ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity don’t just summarize what’s on your website. They pull insights from the broader web — and review sites have become some of their favorite sources.

When a user types a question like:

ChatGPT doesn’t rely on your own content. It looks at what real users are saying across G2, TrustRadius, and Capterra.

It analyzes review sentiment, how recent those reviews are, and how consistent your reputation looks across multiple sites.

That means your customer reviews don’t just influence buyers. They instead influence algorithms.

If people consistently describe your product as “reliable,” “easy to use,” or “worth the price,” those signals make their way into AI search rankings.

The next time someone asks ChatGPT for “top-rated tools” or “best local options,” your brand is more likely to show up in the answer.

In other words, a single five-star review could eventually turn into a ChatGPT citation.

The Review Flywheel: How To Win in 2025 and Beyond

You can’t fake reviews.

But you can create an environment that naturally encourages more of them… what I like to call the review flywheel.

Here’s how it works.

Step one: Ask your happiest customers at the right time.

The best moment to request a review is right after a success — when your product or service has delivered a real result. Catch people while they’re genuinely excited.

Step two: Make it easy.

Don’t send a long form or ask them to find your profile on their own. Give them a direct link to your preferred platform and keep the request simple.

Step three: Respond to every review…especially the negative ones.

When people see that you care enough to engage publicly, it builds credibility. It also keeps your review page active and signals to both customers and AI engines that your brand is responsive.

Step four: Repurpose your best reviews across your ecosystem.

Pull snippets into your website, share them on social media, and use schema markup so that AI search engines can parse and display them properly.

This isn’t just good marketing hygiene. It’s an SEO advantage for the AI era.

Step five: Measure your visibility lift.

Use tools that can tell you when your brand starts being cited or mentioned in AI-generated results. When you track that progress, you’ll see a direct line between reviews and discoverability.

When done right, this turns into a self-reinforcing loop:

Happy customers leave reviews → AI picks up those reviews → more buyers discover your brand → more customers leave reviews.

That’s your review flywheel.

The Big Picture: Reviews Are the New Backlinks

Here’s the bigger trend.

Traditional SEO is fading. AI search is taking over.

Google and ChatGPT aren’t just ranking pages anymore…they’re ranking brands.

And when credibility is the metric, reviews become the new backlinks.

They’re the clearest, most authentic signal that real people trust what you’re selling.

Think about it this way:

• Review volume is your new domain authority.

• Review recency is your freshness signal.

• Review sentiment is your credibility score.

You can’t buy your way into AI search results.

You have to earn it through consistent, verifiable, customer-driven proof.

Every positive review you earn today becomes part of your digital reputation, the same one ChatGPT and other AI systems will use to decide whether to recommend you tomorrow.

That’s a huge shift. And it’s already happening.

Final Thought

In the age of AI, reviews are no longer feedback.

They’re visibility assets.

Each new review you collect increases your chances of being found, trusted, and selected — by both people and AI.

So make reviews part of your marketing system.

Ask for them. Make it easy. Respond quickly.

And let your customers become the voice that drives your next wave of growth.

Because when ChatGPT and your buyers agree about your brand, you’ve already won.

Jason Patel
Co-founder & CEO, Open Forge AI
We help your business get seen, cited, and selected by AI search engines.

Answer Engine Optimization Strategies

If you liked this newsletter, feel free to forward to your friends in marketing and AI.

If you got this from a friend, you can sign up to get the newsletter: https://aen.beehiiv.com/subscribe