Thanks for reading. Feedback?
Reply to this email or message [email protected]

Get seen, cited, and selected by AI search engines.

Book a free trial here.

Let’s get into it

How Small Brands Are Beating Giants in AI Search (And How You Can Too)

AI search is your chance to beat the giants in your space. Here's how:

While billion-dollar companies pour millions into AI optimization, a small Portland coffee roaster just outranked Starbucks in ChatGPT's recommendations.

Their secret? Strategies that big corporations literally cannot copy.

The New Reality of AI Search

If you're running a small business, you're probably worried about AI. Every day brings headlines about ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Claude changing how people find products and services.

But here's what nobody's telling you: AI actually levels the playing field in ways that favor small brands.

After analyzing hundreds of small brands winning in AI search, we've identified five specific advantages they're using. These aren't complex technical hacks.

They're simple strategies that work because of how AI fundamentally operates.

Advantage #1: Authentic, Founder-Led Content

Why It Works

AI models can distinguish between authentic human stories and corporate messaging. They're trained on millions of examples and have learned to recognize genuineness.

Think about when you read a press release versus a founder sharing their story.

You can feel the difference, right? AI models have learned to recognize this difference too.

Case Study: Beardbrand

Eric Bandholz started Beardbrand in 2012 as just a guy with a beard who couldn't find products he liked. He began creating YouTube videos from his apartment with no script, no production team, just Eric talking to a camera about beards.

Today, Beardbrand generates over $10 million in annual revenue. When you ask ChatGPT about beard care, Beardbrand often appears before Gillette, a company that spends more on a single Super Bowl ad than Beardbrand has spent on marketing in its entire existence.

What Makes Founder Content Powerful

Natural Uniqueness

Your story, perspective, and way of explaining things is fingerprint-level unique. Corporate content teams try to sound professional and end up sounding like everyone else. You sound like you because you ARE you.

Higher Engagement

When you share personal failures or victories, people connect. They comment, share, and remember. AI models track all these engagement signals and use them to determine authority and relevance.

Speed Advantage

While a big company needs five meetings to approve a tweet, you can respond to a customer question with a 10-minute video that becomes the definitive answer on that topic.

Implementation Strategy

Start documenting everything:

• Customer conversations that surprise you

• The messy middle of product development

• Your biggest mistakes and what you learned

• Small wins that might seem insignificant

The key is sharing the real journey. Talk about the time you almost quit, the product launch that flopped, the customer complaint that changed everything. This real-world context is gold for AI understanding.

Respond personally to everything. When someone comments on your content or asks a question, your personal response becomes part of your content footprint that AI indexes. Create content in your natural environment. If you're building products in your garage, film there. Authenticity beats production value every time.

Advantage #2: Hyper-Specialization in Micro-Niches

Why It Works

While big companies chase massive markets, AI rewards depth over breadth. Going so narrow that big companies won't bother competing with you creates an advantage they can't match.

Case Study: The Chess Store

The Chess Store sells only chess products. Not board games, not puzzles, just chess sets, boards, pieces, books, and software. Amazon probably has 10 times their selection, but when you ask AI about buying chess equipment, The Chess Store consistently ranks higher.

Why? They've created over 500 pieces of content specifically about chess:

• The history of specific chess pieces

• Guides on choosing the right wood for chess boards

• Deep dives into chess notation systems

• Articles about chess sets for players with arthritis

They're doing over $5 million annually selling nothing but chess products. This is what going an inch wide and a mile deep looks like in practice.

The Power of Going Deep

When everything you create is about one specific topic, you build topical authority that's almost impossible to beat. AI models look for expertise signals, and consistent depth in one area sends those signals loud and clear.

You can cover angles that big companies won't touch. Amazon isn't going to write a 3,000-word guide on "Choosing Chess Sets for Players with Arthritis," but The Chess Store did, and now they own that entire search vertical.

Your audience engagement also goes through the roof. When someone finds ultra-specific content that speaks exactly to their needs, they stick around. They read everything. They share it with others who have that same specific interest.

Finding Your Micro-Niche

Start with what you know, then narrow it down three times. Let's say you know fitness. That's too broad. Strength training? Still too broad. Powerlifting? Getting warmer. Powerlifting for women over 40? Now we're talking.

Create content that answers every possible question in your micro-niche. Think about questions so specific that nobody else would bother answering them. Then answer them in painful detail. Build tools and resources specifically for your micro-audience. Use naturally specific language that your audience uses.

The best part? Big companies literally can't follow you here. It's not worth it for Nike to create 500 pieces of content about running shoes for nurses who work night shifts. But for you? That could be your entire business.

Advantage #3: Obsessive Customer Experience

Why It Works

Your biggest weakness (size) becomes your biggest strength. You can care about customers in ways that big companies simply cannot match. And in the AI era, that creates a content and visibility advantage that money can't buy.

Case Study: Chewy

Chewy started as a tiny online pet store competing against PetSmart, Petco, and Amazon. They did something radical: they actually cared about their customers' pets.

When a customer's pet passed away, Chewy would send flowers and a handwritten note. When they noticed a customer hadn't reordered food in a while, they'd reach out to check if everything was okay. They had artists on staff who would paint portraits of customers' pets and send them as surprise gifts.

Every single one of these gestures turned into organic content. Customers would post photos of the flowers, share screenshots of the caring emails, frame the pet portraits and put them on social media. Chewy sold for $3.35 billion, built largely on customer experience stories that spread organically.

How Great Service Creates AI Visibility

Great service generates authentic user-generated content. Every amazing customer experience becomes a story that gets shared, posted, reviewed, and indexed by AI. It creates brand searches when people tell others to "check out Chewy" or "you have to try this company." These direct brand searches are gold for AI understanding.

It also builds sentiment signals that AI tracks. Positive mentions, emotional language, recommendation patterns all feed into how AI perceives your brand authority.

Building Your Service Content Engine

Respond to everything, everywhere. Every comment, review, question, complaint becomes an opportunity to create indexable content that shows you care. Go overboard on personal touches:

• Handwritten notes that surprise people

• Custom videos addressing their specific situation

• Unexpected gifts that relate to their interests

• Remembering details that matter to them

Turn customer questions into comprehensive content. When someone asks you something, don't just answer them. Create a piece of content that answers it thoroughly, then send them that content. Now you've helped them AND created something AI can index.

Document your customer service philosophy. Write about why you do what you do. Share behind-the-scenes looks at how you handle issues. Make customers the heroes of your stories instead of talking about your great service.

Advantage #4: Experimental Content Formats

Why It Works

While big brands are having meetings about their meetings to discuss maybe trying something new, you can launch 10 experimental content formats before lunch. AI loves novel content formats because they represent new information patterns to learn from.

Case Study: Cometeer (Frozen Coffee)

Cometeer decided to get weird with their content. Really weird. They created:

• A TikTok series teaching coffee science through interpretive dance

• An AI chatbot that writes custom coffee haikus based on taste preferences

• AR filters showing coffee molecules dancing when you point your phone at products

• Interactive taste profile quizzes that generate personalized coffee recommendations

Is it strange? Absolutely. Is it working? They're now competing head-to-head with Nespresso in the premium coffee space.

Why Experimental Content Wins

Novelty gets noticed. When AI encounters content formats it hasn't seen before, it pays attention. You become the defining example of that format in your space. There's also less competition. Everyone's fighting over blog posts and standard videos. Nobody's competing in the "coffee education through interpretive dance" category.

Experimental formats show innovation signals. AI models are trained to recognize innovation and freshness. These formats scream "cutting edge" in a way that your 50th blog post doesn't.

Experimentation Framework

Launch something new every week. Set aside time to try a completely new content format. Most will fail, and that's fine. You only need a few hits. Combine things that don't belong together:

• Educational content + entertainment

• Product demos + ASMR

• Customer testimonials + musical theater

• Data visualization + storytelling

Create interactive experiences like quizzes, calculators, AR filters, or mini-games. Test AI-specific formats designed for AI consumption. Document everything, including your failures. Behind-the-scenes content about your experiments often performs better than the experiments themselves.

Big brands can't do this. They have brand guidelines, legal departments, and approval processes that kill innovation. You can go from idea to published in an hour. Use that speed.

Advantage #5: Lightning-Fast Trend Response

Why It Works

In the AI era, being first matters more than being perfect. Small brands can move at speeds that make big corporations look like they're stuck in quicksand.

Case Study: Gymshark

Started by a 19-year-old in his garage in 2012, Gymshark is now worth over $1.3 billion. How? Speed.

When a new fitness trend emerged, Gymshark had content about it within hours. New workout going viral on TikTok? Gymshark athletes were doing it before Nike's marketing team even heard about it. Fitness influencer creates a new challenge? Gymshark already made custom gear for it.

They didn't outspend the big brands. They just moved faster. Way faster.

Speed as Competitive Advantage

AI models prioritize recent, relevant content. Being first means you define the conversation around new topics. Early content accumulates engagement over time. By the time big brands show up, you've already built authority. When you consistently jump on trends early, AI starts associating your brand with innovation and relevance.

Building Your Rapid Response System

Set up monitoring everywhere:

• Google Alerts for your niche keywords

• Social media monitoring for emerging topics

• Reddit tracking for community discussions

• TikTok trend spotting for viral moments

Create content templates so you can plug in new information and publish fast. Build a rapid response mindset where your first thought is "how can I create content about this right now?"

Connect everything to your niche. A celebrity wore something interesting? If you sell accessories, create content about how to get the look. New AI tool launched? Show how it applies to your industry. Everything connects if you're creative enough.

Give yourself permission to be imperfect. A good piece of content published today beats a perfect piece published next week. You can always update and improve later.

Your Action Plan

Step 1: Audit Your Current Advantages

Ask yourself which of these advantages you're already using, even accidentally. What comes naturally to you? Where do you have the most energy? Start there and double down.

Step 2: Pick Your Focus

Choose one or two advantages based on:

• Your personal strengths (are you naturally fast, creative, or personable?)

• Your market opportunities (what's missing in your space?)

• Your available time (some advantages require more consistency)

• Your comfort zone (push it, but don't break it)

Step 3: Create Systems

For founder content, schedule regular recording times and story collection. For niche focus, build a content calendar around deep topics. For customer service, create surprise and delight processes. For experiments, block innovation time. For speed, build monitoring dashboards.

Step 4: Measure What Matters

Track your brand mentions in AI responses, organic traffic from AI-driven searches, engagement rates on different content types, and speed to market on trends. Focus on metrics that show authority building, not vanity metrics.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Trying Everything at Once

Pick one or two advantages maximum. Master them before adding more. Depth beats breadth in everything, including strategy implementation.

Copying Big Brand Tactics

Their playbook doesn't work for you. Your advantages are different. Play your own game with your own rules.

Perfectionism

Speed beats perfection. You can always improve later. Motion creates clarity and momentum.

Giving Up Too Soon

These advantages compound over time. Expect 60-90 days for initial traction, 6-12 months for significant results. Consistency is everything.

Ignoring Your Strengths

Don't force unnatural advantages. If you hate being on camera, don't force founder-led video content. Lean into what you're good at. Authenticity always wins.

The Bottom Line

AI doesn't care about your marketing budget. It cares about value, authenticity, expertise, innovation, and relevance. These are all things you can deliver better than any big corporation.

Stop trying to outspend them, out-SEO them, or out-advertise them. Start being more human, more focused, more caring, more experimental, and more responsive.

That's how you win in the AI era. Not by playing their game better, but by playing a completely different game. A game where being small isn't a disadvantage. It's your secret weapon.

The giants have money, but you have agility, authenticity, and the ability to actually care. In the AI era, those are the ultimate weapons. Pick your advantage, go all in, and watch what happens when you stop playing by their rules.

Jason Patel
Co-founder & CEO, Open Forge AI
We help your business get seen, cited, and selected by AI search engines.

Answer Engine Optimization Strategies and Tips

If you liked this newsletter, feel free to forward to your friends in marketing and AI.

If you got this from a friend, you can sign up to get the newsletter: https://aen.beehiiv.com/subscribe