Thanks for reading. Feedback?
Reply to this email or message [email protected]

Subscribe to My YouTube Channel
 

Let’s get into it

Clicks Are Dying. Smart Marketers Are Tracking This Instead

Your Website Clicks Are Dropping (But That's Good News)

Your website clicks are dropping, but that might actually be good news. While most marketers are panicking about their traffic numbers, the smart ones are celebrating because they know something you don't.

Here's what's really happening and why you should care.

The Era of Zero-Click Search Is Here

We're living through the biggest shift in how people find information since Google launched 25 years ago. It's called zero-click search, and it's changing everything about how your customers discover and interact with your business.

What's happening right now:

• When someone asks ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini a question, they get their answer right there in the chat

• No clicking through to your website

• No browsing multiple pages

• They get what they need instantly

This isn't some future trend we're speculating about. It's happening right now.

The current impact:

• Businesses across every industry are seeing traffic drops of 20 to 30 percent

• Some are seeing even bigger drops

• The knee-jerk reaction? Panic

• But that's the wrong response

Think about it from your customer's perspective. They want answers, not a treasure hunt through your website. AI search engines are giving them exactly that: fast, relevant, personalized answers without the friction of clicking around multiple sites.

The massive shift:

• Traditional search used to send people on a journey

• They'd search, click a result, maybe click a few more, compare options, and eventually take action

• Now? AI gives them the answer immediately

• If they want to take action, they're already primed and ready

Why Declining Clicks Aren't the Problem

Here's where most marketers get it wrong. They see fewer clicks and assume their marketing is failing. But that's like a restaurant owner complaining that fewer people are reading the menu because more customers know exactly what they want when they walk in.

The truth is, AI is doing you a favor:

• It's pre-qualifying your traffic

• When someone finally does click through to your site after interacting with AI, they're not just browsing

• They're not killing time

• They're not comparison shopping just for fun

• They know what they want, and they're ready to act

This is the difference between spray-and-pray marketing and precision marketing. In the old world, you cast a wide net and hoped something stuck. Now, AI is filtering out the tire-kickers and sending you people with real intent.

A concrete example:

Say you run a marketing agency. In the past, someone might Google "digital marketing services," click through five different agency websites, spend 30 seconds on each one, and leave without taking action. That's five clicks but zero value.

Now, that same person asks Claude, "What should I look for in a digital marketing agency for my SaaS startup?" Claude gives them a detailed answer, mentions a few key qualities to look for, and maybe even suggests they check out agencies that specialize in SaaS. When they finally visit your site, they're not just browsing. They're evaluating whether you're the right fit. That's one click with massive value.

Conversions: The New North Star

This brings us to the metric that actually matters: conversions. A conversion is any action that moves someone closer to becoming your customer.

Examples of conversions:

• Filling out a lead form

• Signing up for a free trial

• Downloading a guide

• Booking a demo

• Making a purchase

Why conversions matter more than clicks in this AI-driven world:

Higher-intent visitors: When AI pre-qualifies your traffic, the people who reach your site are already interested in what you offer. They're not accidental visitors or casual browsers. They're potential customers.

Better ROI from your marketing spend: Would you rather pay for 1,000 random clicks or 100 clicks from people ready to buy? The math is obvious. Quality beats quantity every time.

More precise measurement of marketing effectiveness: Clicks tell you how many people visited your site. Conversions tell you how many people actually cared enough to take action. One measures activity, the other measures results.

Here's what's really interesting. Companies that have embraced this shift are seeing their conversion rates double or even triple, even as their overall traffic decreases. They're making more money with fewer visitors because those visitors are better qualified.

How to Track Conversions Accurately

If conversions are your new north star, you need to track them properly. Most businesses are still flying blind here, and it's costing them big time.

Start with the basics:

• Google Analytics 4 (GA4) is free and built for conversion tracking

• Set up conversion goals for every important action on your site

• Lead form submissions, newsletter signups, demo requests, purchases: track all of it

Don't stop there. If you're serious about understanding your conversions, you need specialized tools. Here’s a good starting point (I am not endorsing these tools BTW):

HubSpot

• Fantastic for B2B companies

• Tracks the entire customer journey from first visit to closed deal

Mixpanel

• Great for SaaS companies

• Tracks user behavior inside your product

Segment

• Acts like a data hub

• Collects information from all your tools and gives you a complete picture

The key steps:

• Define your conversion goals clearly before you start tracking

• A conversion isn't just any action, it's a meaningful action that indicates genuine interest or intent

• Someone downloading your pricing guide? That's a conversion

• Someone clicking on your About page? Probably not

Additional tracking essentials:

• Use UTM parameters to track where your conversions are coming from

• Create dedicated landing pages for different campaigns so you can see exactly which messages and offers are working

• Make sure your tracking pixels and tags are properly implemented

• Bad data is worse than no data

What's a Good Conversion Rate?

This is the question everyone asks, and the answer is: it depends. But I'll give you some benchmarks to work with.

Site-wide conversion rates:

• Most websites see between 2 and 5 percent

• That means out of every 100 visitors, 2 to 5 take some kind of meaningful action

• But site-wide conversion rates don't tell the whole story

High-performing landing pages:

• Should convert much better

• We're talking 10 to 15 percent or even higher

• If you're sending targeted traffic to a focused landing page with a clear offer, and you're only converting 2 percent of visitors, something's wrong

Context matters more than generic benchmarks:

• A B2B software company selling enterprise solutions will have different conversion rates than an e-commerce store selling consumer products

• A high-ticket service will convert differently than a low-cost subscription

Focus on your own improvement:

• Instead of obsessing over industry averages, focus on your own baseline and improve from there

• If you're converting 3 percent of visitors today, can you get to 4 percent next month?

• Can you get to 6 percent by the end of the quarter?

• That kind of improvement compounds quickly

Remember traffic source differences:

• Different traffic sources will have different conversion rates

• Someone who finds you through AI search and clicks through with high intent should convert much better than someone who stumbles across your site through social media

Tools to Improve Conversion Rates

Once you're tracking conversions properly, you need to optimize them. This is where the real magic happens.

A/B Testing Tools

• Optimizely or Google Optimize

• Test different versions of your pages to see what works better

• Change your headline, try a different call-to-action button, test a new layout

• Small changes can have big impacts on your conversion rates

Heatmap and Session Recording Tools

• Hotjar or Crazy Egg

• Show you exactly how visitors interact with your site

• You can see where they click, how far they scroll, and where they get stuck

• This gives you insights you can't get from traditional analytics

Chatbots and Conversational Marketing Tools

• Drift or Intercom

• Can capture visitors who might otherwise leave without converting

• Someone browsing your pricing page at 2 AM might not fill out a contact form, but they might chat with a bot and book a demo for later

Personalization Tools

• Mutiny or VWO

• Let you show different messages to different visitors based on their behavior, location, or referral source

• Someone coming from AI search might see different content than someone coming from social media

The key is to use these tools systematically, not randomly:

• Start with your highest-traffic pages and your most important conversion goals

• Make one change at a time so you know what's actually moving the needle

Strategies for Maximizing High-Intent Traffic

Since AI is sending you higher-intent visitors, you need to be ready for them. Your website needs to convert these motivated visitors efficiently.

Optimize your landing pages for clarity and simplicity

• High-intent visitors know what they want, but they don't want to hunt for it

• Make your value proposition clear within five seconds of someone landing on your page

• Use headlines that match their intent, not clever marketing speak

Create urgency without being pushy

• High-intent visitors are often comparing options

• Give them a reason to choose you and choose you now

• Limited-time offers, exclusive bonuses, or clear timelines can help push them over the edge

Personalize your messaging based on how people found you

• Someone who arrived after asking ChatGPT about "best CRM for real estate" should see different messaging than someone who clicked through from a generic ad

Implement immediate follow-ups

• High-intent visitors who don't convert on their first visit are still valuable prospects

• Capture their email address and follow up with relevant content

• Set up retargeting ads to stay in front of them as they make their decision

Make your conversion process as frictionless as possible

• Long forms kill conversions

• Confusing checkout processes kill sales

• Broken links kill everything

• Test your conversion process regularly and fix any friction points immediately

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Let me save you some headaches by calling out the biggest mistakes I see companies make when trying to optimize for conversions.

Ignoring mobile optimization

• More than half of your traffic is probably coming from mobile devices

• Mobile users behave differently than desktop users

• Your mobile conversion process needs to be flawless

• If someone can't easily convert on their phone, you're losing money

Giving visitors too many choices

• Decision paralysis is real

• When someone lands on your pricing page and sees eight different plans with dozens of features, they often choose nothing

• Simplify your options and guide people toward the choice that makes the most sense for them

Not testing regularly, or worse, not testing at all

• Your conversion rates aren't set in stone

• Small changes in your copy, design, or process can have huge impacts

• But you'll never know unless you test

• Set up a systematic testing schedule and stick to it

Focusing only on the conversion point and ignoring the journey that leads to it

• If someone converts on your contact form, that's great

• But what convinced them to fill it out?

• Was it your homepage, a specific blog post, your about page?

• Understanding the full customer journey helps you optimize the entire experience

Treating all conversions as equal

• A newsletter signup is not the same as a demo request

• A free trial signup is not the same as a purchase

• Weight your conversions based on their value to your business and optimize accordingly

The Bottom Line

The marketing landscape has fundamentally changed. Clicks are becoming less relevant every day, while conversions are becoming more important than ever. AI search engines are pre-qualifying your traffic and sending you visitors with higher intent and clearer needs.

This isn't a problem to solve. It's an opportunity to embrace. Companies that adapt to this new reality will dominate their markets. Companies that cling to old metrics will get left behind.

The formula is simple:

• Track conversions properly

• Optimize your conversion process systematically

• Focus on the quality of your traffic rather than the quantity

Do this consistently, and you'll build a more efficient, more profitable marketing machine.

Remember, in the age of AI, it's not about how many people see your message. It's about how many people act on it.

Quick Reference FAQ

What exactly is a conversion? A conversion is any meaningful action that moves someone closer to becoming your customer. This could be filling out a contact form, signing up for a free trial, downloading a guide, booking a demo, or making a purchase. The key is that it indicates genuine interest or intent.

How do I know if my conversion rate is good? Most websites see conversion rates between 2 and 5 percent, but this varies greatly by industry and traffic source. Focus more on improving your own baseline than comparing to industry averages. If you're at 3 percent today, aim for 4 percent next month.

What's the most important conversion tracking tool to start with? Google Analytics 4 (GA4) is the best starting point because it's free and comprehensive. Set up conversion goals for all your important actions first, then consider adding specialized tools like HubSpot or Mixpanel as you grow.

Should I be worried about declining website traffic? Not necessarily. If your traffic is declining but your conversion rate is increasing, you might actually be in a better position. Quality traffic that converts is much more valuable than high traffic that doesn't take action.

How often should I test and optimize my conversion rates? Run continuous A/B tests, but give each test enough time to gather meaningful data, usually 2 to 4 weeks depending on your traffic volume. Focus on testing one element at a time so you know what's actually impacting your results.

Can small businesses compete with big companies in this new landscape? Absolutely. In fact, small businesses often have an advantage because they can move faster and provide more personalized experiences. Focus on serving your ideal customers exceptionally well rather than trying to appeal to everyone.

Questions about implementing these strategies?

Reply to this email - I read every response and often answer personally.

Jason Patel
Co-founder & CEO, Open Forge AI
We help your business get seen, cited, and selected by AI search engines.

Answer Engine Optimization Strategies and Tips

If you liked this newsletter, feel free to forward to your friends in marketing and AI.

If you got this from a friend, you can sign up to get the newsletter: https://aen.beehiiv.com/subscribe