ChatGPT Uses These 2 Signals to Decide Who Gets Seen, Cited, and Selected

Thanks for reading. Feedback?
Reply to this email or message [email protected]

Let’s get into it

ChatGPT Uses These 2 Signals to Decide Who Gets Seen, Cited, and Selected

AI search engines use completely different criteria. Focus on these two.

I'm watching businesses spend thousands of dollars on link-building campaigns and keyword optimization strategies that worked great in 2019.

But they're completely missing what AI search engines actually care about in 2025.

After analyzing thousands of AI search results and working with 100 companies to get them featured in AI responses, I've identified the two core signals that determine whether your business gets selected or gets ignored.

The fundamental difference: When someone asks ChatGPT "What's the best project management tool for remote teams?" the AI isn't just randomly picking websites to reference.

There's a sophisticated selection process happening behind the scenes.

These AI models are trained to provide the most helpful, accurate, and comprehensive answers possible. They're not trying to game search rankings or maximize ad revenue like traditional search engines.

This means the signals they prioritize are completely different from what Google has trained us to focus on.

Signal #1: Information Gain Through Proprietary Content

The first signal that makes AI search engines sit up and pay attention is what I call "information gain."

This is content that teaches something genuinely new or provides insights that can't be found anywhere else.

Think about it from the AI's perspective: If it's trying to give someone the best possible answer, it wants to include sources that add unique value to the conversation.

Content that just rehashes the same advice everyone else is giving doesn't move the needle.

Here's what information gain actually looks like:

• Proprietary Concepts and Frameworks The businesses getting featured most often are creating their own methodologies, frameworks, and concepts. They're not just explaining "how to do email marketing." They're introducing "The 3-Layer Email Nurture System" or "The CONVERT Framework for Newsletter Growth."

• Deep Comparison Content Detailed comparisons that go beyond surface-level feature lists. This isn't just "Slack vs Microsoft Teams." This is "I spent 30 days managing remote teams with 5 different tools. Here's what actually happened with productivity, adoption rates, and hidden costs nobody talks about."

• Hyper-Specific Industry Content AI engines actively seek out hyper-specific content because it helps them provide more relevant answers. A generic article about "marketing strategies" rarely gets cited. But "Email marketing strategies for B2B SaaS companies with 50-200 employees" gets referenced constantly.

• Comprehensive FAQ Resources AI models love comprehensive FAQ resources because they're specifically designed to answer questions. We're talking about FAQs that address the real questions people have but are afraid to ask. The insider knowledge. The edge cases.

• Industry-Specific Checklists Practical, actionable checklists tailored to specific industries. Not "Social Media Checklist" but "Pre-Launch Social Media Checklist for B2B SaaS Startups."

• Proof Pages and Case Studies AI engines increasingly cite proof pages when people ask for recommendations or want to verify if something actually works. But the key is specificity. Detailed case studies, complete with specific metrics, challenges, and outcomes, are consistently referenced.

The pattern is clear: It's about having proprietary content that genuinely adds something new to the conversation.

Signal #2: Third-Party Citations and Reputation Indicators

The second major signal AI search engines use is third-party citations and reputation indicators.

This isn't the same as traditional SEO backlinks.

AI models don't just count links. They evaluate the credibility and relevance of sources that mention or reference your business.

Key citation sources that matter:

• Wikipedia and Industry Authority Wikipedia remains incredibly influential with AI search engines, especially for established industries and larger companies. Industry-specific Wikipedia pages often reference smaller companies that are pioneers in specific niches.

• Review Sites and Industry Directories For e-commerce and B2B SaaS companies, getting featured on relevant review sites is crucial for AI visibility. AI engines frequently cite G2, Capterra, Trustpilot when people ask for recommendations.

• Industry Roundups and Expert Lists Getting featured in industry roundup articles is one of the most underrated ways to build AI search authority. When reputable publications include your company in "Top 10 Marketing Automation Tools," AI engines take notice.

• Podcast Citations and Speaking Mentions AI engines recognize when experts are cited across different media formats. When you're consistently mentioned as an expert across multiple podcasts and industry publications, AI models start recognizing you as an authoritative voice.

The problem with spammy backlinks:

Those spammy backlink schemes that might have helped with Google rankings? They're completely useless for AI search visibility.

AI engines are sophisticated enough to recognize low-quality, irrelevant citations. Having too many spammy backlinks might actually hurt your AI search visibility because it signals you're trying to game the system.

The focus needs to shift from quantity of backlinks to quality of citations.

One mention in a highly relevant, authoritative source is worth more than hundreds of directory listings or guest posts on irrelevant sites.

Why These Signals Matter More Than Traditional SEO

The fundamental difference between traditional search and AI search is intent and methodology.

Google is trying to serve the most relevant pages based on keywords and authority signals.

AI engines are trying to provide the most helpful and accurate information to directly answer questions.

This means traditional SEO tactics like keyword density, meta descriptions, and link quantity become less important, while content quality, uniqueness, and authoritative citations become everything.

AI engines don't care if you rank #1 on Google for a keyword. They care if you have the best information to help answer someone's specific question.

The Competitive Advantage

Here's why this matters so much right now:

Most businesses are still focused on traditional SEO metrics. They're optimizing for Google rankings while AI search usage explodes.

According to recent studies, AI search queries are growing 400% faster than traditional search queries.

People are increasingly turning to ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity instead of Google for research and recommendations.

The businesses that understand these signals and optimize for AI visibility now are going to have a massive competitive advantage over the next few years.

While your competitors are still buying spammy backlinks and stuffing keywords into content, you can be building genuine expertise recognition and creating truly valuable content that AI engines love to cite.

Moving Forward

The question is whether you're going to adapt your content strategy to succeed in this new environment or keep playing by outdated rules.

Here's what you need to focus on:

• Create content that genuinely teaches something new

• Build relationships with authoritative sources in your industry

• Stop chasing generic keywords and start solving specific problems for specific audiences

• Develop proprietary frameworks and methodologies

• Get featured in legitimate industry publications and review sites

The businesses that make this shift now will dominate AI search results while their competitors wonder where all their traffic went.

Bottom line: Focus on creating genuinely valuable, unique content and building real industry authority. That's how you win in the age of AI search.

Talk soon,

Jason Patel
Co-founder & CEO, Open Forge AI
We help your business get seen, cited, and selected by AI search engines.

Answer Engine Optimization Strategies

If you liked this newsletter, feel free to forward to your friends in marketing and AI.

If you got this from a friend, you can sign up to get the newsletter: https://aen.beehiiv.com/subscribe